The Muttontown Club
East Norwich, NY · Founded
The Muttontown Club is a private golf club in East Norwich, New York, designed by Alfred H. Tull in 1923. The club has 18 holes. The average member handicap is 16.4 with 22% single-digit players. Estimated initiation fee is $25,000 with monthly dues of $500.
Alfred Tull's 1923 Gold Coast creation occupies the kind of manicured Long Island estate where Gatsby himself might have played, preserving Jazz Age elegance in modern times.
Estimated Membership Costs
Fees are estimated and may vary by membership category. Source: research. Last updated March 2026. Is this incorrect? Claim this club to update.
View full membership cost breakdown →Amenities
Member Profile
Based on GHIN handicap data. Individual member information is not stored or displayed.
About The Muttontown Club
The course winds through what was once part of the Whitney family estate, where each hole feels like a journey through gilded age grandeur. Tull's routing maximizes the property's natural amphitheater setting, creating intimate golf despite the expansive acreage. The club's commitment to period authenticity extends beyond architecture—this is time travel disguised as golf.
Key Facts
- The Muttontown Club is located in East Norwich, New York.
- Club type: private.
- Course architect: Alfred H. Tull.
- Year founded: 1923.
- Number of holes: 18.
- Average member handicap: 16.4.
- Single-digit handicap players: 22%.
- GHIN-registered members: 24.
- Estimated initiation fee: $25,000.
- Estimated monthly dues: $500.
- Membership types: private.
- Amenities include: Driving Range, Golf Carts, Dining, Swimming Pool.
- Alister Index score: 72/100.
